Paint vs. Wallpaper: How to Choose the Best Finish for Your Walls

If you’re planning to refresh a room, the choice between paint and wallpaper can feel like a big one. Both have the power to completely transform your space—but they differ in cost, upkeep, and design impact. And while paint remains the go-to for quick and affordable updates, wallpaper has been making a serious comeback for those ready to commit to pattern, texture, and personality.

In this post, we’re breaking down the pros and cons of paint and wallpaper, including when to choose one over the other, how each holds up over time, and insider tips for getting the best results—no matter which you pick.

Cost: Paint is Budget-Friendly, Wallpaper is a Splurge

• Paint averages about half the cost of wallpaper.
• Ideal for quick turnarounds and DIY updates—no pro required for good results.
• Wallpaper costs more—especially factoring in labor—but offers dramatic design impact.
• Budget tip: Use wallpaper above chair rail moulding and paint below for a cost-effective statement wall.

If you’re working with a tight budget or love to change your look often, paint wins. It averages about half the cost of wallpaper and doesn’t require a professional to get a great result. Designers often talk about the “power of paint,” and it’s no joke—it can completely transform a room in just a weekend.

Wallpaper, on the other hand, comes with a higher price tag—especially when you factor in labor. But the payoff is big: the design impact is next level. If your budget won’t stretch to wallpaper an entire room, consider using it above chair rail molding or wainscoting, and paint the rest in a complementary shade for a layered, high-end look.

Design Impact: Subtle vs. Statement

• Paint: simple color change, subtle personality shift, and instant refresh.
• Wallpaper: pattern, texture, and personality that elevates a space to the next level.
• Examples of when each shines (e.g., small powder rooms for wallpaper, large living rooms for paint).

Paint changes the mood of a room instantly and offers endless color possibilities. It’s great for subtle personality shifts and easy seasonal updates.

Wallpaper, however, is your ticket to drama. From bold florals to tailored grasscloth, it adds depth, texture, and a sense of luxury that paint alone can’t match. If you want your walls to become a focal point, wallpaper is the way to go.

Durability & Longevity: Wallpaper Holds the Upper Hand

• Wallpaper: lasts 10–15 years with minimal maintenance if installed well.
• Paint: needs more frequent touch-ups or repaints—especially in high-traffic homes.

A quality wallpaper installation can last 10 to 15 years with minimal maintenance. Painted walls, especially in high-traffic areas, often need touch-ups or a full repaint every few years.

That said, wallpaper isn’t invincible—occasional seam lifting or small tears can happen, but repairs are usually minor (and much easier if you keep extra rolls on hand).

Maintenance: Which Holds Up Better?

• Paint: prone to scuffs, dings, and scratches (especially with kids or pets).
• Wallpaper: fewer touch-ups, but seams can lift or tear; keep extra rolls for repairs.
• Caution: wallpaper is not ideal for playrooms or high-moisture areas unless specialty material is used.

Paint shows wear faster. Homes with kids, pets, or a lot of activity will likely see scuffs, scratches, and marks that require regular touch-ups.

Wallpaper, when installed well, handles daily life with more grace—though it’s not the best choice for playrooms or high-moisture areas unless you use a specialty material.

Installation & Prep Work: Paint Wins for Flexibility

• Paint: easier prep and cleanup, flexible if you want to change later.
• Wallpaper: requires perfectly smooth walls, precise placement, sticky paste, and more cleanup.
• Removal can be a project—sometimes best left to pros.
• Personal anecdote: the floral wallpaper in your daughter’s nursery and why you recommend hiring an installer.

Paint is forgiving, relatively quick, and easy to change down the line. It still requires prep work—taping, drop cloths, and cleanup—but wallpaper takes the installation process to another level. Smooth walls, precise placement, sticky paste, and cleanup of scraps all add time and complexity.

And if you’ve ever removed wallpaper, you know it’s a commitment—sometimes a full-day project. Unless you have a wallpaper-hanging expert in the family, it’s worth hiring a pro. (Trust me—I learned this first-hand while hanging a gorgeous floral paper in my daughter’s nursery. It turned out beautifully, but it sealed my belief that a professional is worth every penny.)

Final Verdict: It’s Not Either/Or

• Paint: best for budget, flexibility, and quick updates.
• Wallpaper: best for making a bold, lasting statement.
• Choosing depends on your timeline, budget, and personality.

Paint is best for fresh, low-commitment updates, while wallpaper is the choice for bold, long-lasting style. The right option depends on your budget, timeline, and how adventurous you want to be.

Pro Tip: You don’t have to choose just one—paint and wallpaper can work together beautifully. Try painting most walls in a neutral and using wallpaper strategically on ceiling, or in a small space like a powder room.

Need Help Deciding?

Choosing between paint and wallpaper can feel overwhelming, especially when you’re trying to picture the end result. That’s where a designer comes in. I’d love to help you create a wall treatment plan that’s timeless, personal, and perfectly suited to your home!

---

WE HAVE MORE SHOPPING AND DESIGN STYLE RESOURCES FOR YOU!

• Want to explore more shoppable design boards? Go to our blog home page and click on your favorite style category!
• If you aren’t sure what your unique style mix is, we can help! Take our style survey here.
• Shop by Style at PHI Home.
• Subscribe to our newsletter by clicking ‘join the list’ below! Our monthly newsletter highlights our latest blog posts, client projects, Peggy’s Picks, design tips, and more.

We know interior design can feel overwhelming—there are so many choices and so little time (especially if you’re balancing work, family, and life!). That’s why we’ve made our services simple if you want more design support:

✓ Full-Service Interior Design (Denver locals) → Perfect for busy professionals who want a turnkey design experience from concept to completion.
✓ Virtual Design (E-Design) → A custom design plan you can shop & implement at your own pace.
✓ Designer for a Day (Denver locals) → Need quick expert guidance? We’ll make a plan in just one day
✓ Video Consultation → A one-hour virtual session where I answer all your design questions & help you make decisions fast!

A note about PHI Home: Some of the products linked in this post are to-the-trade pieces from our shop, PHI Home. Typically to-the-trade pieces are purchased exclusively by trade professionals (i.e. interior designers) at wholesale, and then resold to their clients at a markup. We’re delighted to extend access to our favorite trade furniture and décor to everyone, regardless of whether you’re our client or not. Should you require a different size or color variation, please don’t hesitate to reach out to us.

Prices at PHI Home are never above the internet minimum advertised price “IMAP” (set by the manufacturer) plus shipping. By using the coupon code PEGGYSAYSMIX, you can enjoy a discount off the IMAP pricing. Moreover, if you come across a lower price from another online retailer, kindly drop us an email at info@peggyhaddadinteriors.com, and we’ll gladly match that price (remember, our pricing includes threshold shipping).

When you choose to shop with us for your premium furniture and décor needs, you’re not only supporting our small business but also the entire interior design industry, rather than a large retail corporation. Your support is greatly appreciated! For further inquiries about our shop, including details
about our return policy, please click here.

---

This post contains affiliate links (we receive a small commission through qualifying purchases. It costs nothing extra for you! Thank you so much for your support.)